top of page
Search

Metal vs. Asphalt: Which Roofing Material is Right for Your Alberta Home?

  • J & D Independant Roofing
  • 6 days ago
  • 4 min read

Your roof is more than just shelter, it’s your home’s first defense against Alberta’s extreme climate. From bone-chilling winters and wind storms to blazing hot summers and heavy rainfall, your roof must withstand it all. But with so many roofing options out there, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is this: Metal vs asphalt?


At J & D Independent Roofing Inc., we’ve helped thousands of Edmonton homeowners navigate this exact question. With over 30 years of roofing expertise, our local, owner-operated team is here to break down the pros and cons of each material so you can make an informed, confident decision.


Alberta Weather: The Real Test of Roofing Strength


Before diving into the features of metal and asphalt, it’s important to understand what your roof will be up against in Alberta:


  • ❄️ Heavy snow loads and ice dams

  • 🌬️ High winds and sudden gusts

  • 🌧️ Spring and summer downpours

  • ☀️ UV damage from long daylight hours

  • 🌡️ Wild temperature swings (-40°C to +30°C)


That’s why choosing the right roofing material is not just aesthetic, it’s functional and financial.


Asphalt Shingles: The Classic Choice


Pros of Asphalt Roofing


1. Cost-Effective Asphalt shingles are more affordable upfront. If you're on a tight budget or roofing a large home, they offer excellent value for their price.


2. Easy Installation & Repair Quick installation means lower labor costs and faster project completion. Damaged shingles can be replaced individually without redoing the whole roof.


3. Wide Variety of Styles From rustic to modern, asphalt shingles come in a wide range of colors, textures, and profiles to match your home’s style.


4. Moderate Lifespan Expect 15–25 years of service if properly installed and maintained, longer with premium shingles.


5. Readily Available No supply issues or long lead times. They’re always in stock and ready to go.


Cons of Asphalt Roofing


1. Shorter Lifespan Compared to metal, asphalt shingles break down faster under UV rays, snow, and ice, especially during extreme temperature shifts.


2. Vulnerability to Wind & Hail Strong winds can lift or tear off shingles. Hail can cause granule loss or cracking.


3. Higher Long-Term Maintenance Shingle roofs may need occasional patching, sealing, or vent replacements over the years.


4. Not Eco-Friendly Most asphalt shingles end up in landfills, and recycling options are limited.


Metal Roofing: The Durable Powerhouse


Pros of Metal Roofing


1. Exceptional Durability Metal roofs can last 40–70 years or more with minimal maintenance, perfect for Edmonton’s demanding conditions.


2. Extreme Weather Resistance They’re built to withstand heavy snow, ice, fire, high winds, and hail. Snow slides off easily, preventing accumulation and ice damming.


3. Energy Efficiency Metal reflects solar radiant heat, helping keep your home cooler in the summer and lowering your energy bills.


4. Environmentally Friendly Most metal roofing is made from recycled materials and is fully recyclable at the end of its life.


5. Long-Term Cost Savings While metal roofing costs more upfront, its low maintenance and longevity pay for themselves over time.


Cons of Metal Roofing


1. Higher Initial Cost Metal roofs can cost 2–3 times more than asphalt shingles. But that’s balanced by their extended lifespan and durability.


2. Installation Requires Expertise Improper installation can lead to noise issues, leaks, or even fastener failures. That’s why you need a qualified, experienced team like J & D Independent Roofing Inc. to install it right.


3. Noise Concerns (Optional) Some homeowners worry about rain or hail noise, but proper insulation and underlayment significantly reduce this.


4. Aesthetic Limitations for Some Homes Although metal comes in many styles (even ones that mimic shingles or slate), some homeowners prefer the traditional look of asphalt.


Side-by-Side Comparison Metal Vs. Asphalt

Feature

Asphalt Shingles

Metal Roofing

Upfront Cost

Lower

Higher

Lifespan

15–25 years

40–70+ years

Weather Resistance

Moderate

Excellent

Snow Shedding

Slow, may build up

Slides off easily

Energy Efficiency

Fair

High

Maintenance

Occasional repairs

Very low

Aesthetic Variety

High

Moderate to high

Eco-Friendliness

Low

High

Noise Dampening

Quieter

May require insulation


Which Roofing Material is Right for Your Alberta Home?


Choose Asphalt Shingles if:


  • You're looking for affordability

  • You plan to sell your home in the near future

  • You want quick installation

  • You prefer a traditional look


Choose Metal Roofing if:


  • You want long-term durability and savings

  • You plan to stay in your home for 20+ years

  • You need superior protection against hail and snow

  • You care about eco-friendly materials


Trust the Experts at J & D Independent Roofing Inc.


Whether you're leaning toward the time-tested charm of asphalt or the rugged reliability of metal, the success of your roofing investment depends on who installs it.


At J & D Independent Roofing Inc., we:


  • Have over 30 years of experience in Alberta roofing

  • Specialize in flat roofs and complex projects

  • Work with residential, commercial, and industrial properties

  • Provide custom solutions for Edmonton’s harsh climate

  • Back our work with trusted warranties and local references


We don’t just build roofs, we build peace of mind.


Ready for a Roof That Lasts?


Let us help you choose the best roofing system for your home or building. We offer honest assessments, free estimates, and unbeatable workmanship.


📍 J & D Independent Roofing Inc. – Serving Edmonton, Alberta

📞 Call us at: 780-447-1360

 
 
 
bottom of page