Metal Roof Myths Busted: What You Really Need to Know Before Switching

Metal roofs have come a long way from the old barn-style sheets most people picture. Today, they’re sleek, modern, durable, and surprisingly energy-efficient. But despite their growing popularity across Edmonton and beyond, metal roofing is still wrapped in myths, misinformation, and outdated assumptions.

At J & D Independent Roofing Inc., we’ve been in the roofing industry for over 30 years. We’ve installed and repaired just about every type of roof under the sun (and snow), and we’re here to say: metal roofs deserve more credit, and less confusion.

So, before you say no to a metal roof because your cousin’s friend said it was too loud in the rain, let’s bust the most common myths wide open, and give you the facts you really need.

Myth #1: Metal Roofs Are Noisy in the Rain

Truth: A properly installed metal roof is no louder than any other roofing system.

We get it. People imagine a tin roof clattering like a snare drum during a thunderstorm. But the reality is completely different. Today’s metal roofs are installed over layers of underlayment, decking, and often insulation, all of which muffle noise.

In fact, many homeowners with metal roofs say they can’t even tell when it’s raining unless they look outside.

Myth #2: Metal Roofing Is Too Expensive

Truth: Yes, the upfront cost is higher, but the long-term savings are massive. Think of a metal roof as the Tesla of roofing. You’ll pay more initially, but you get:

• A lifespan of 40–70 years (compared to 12–20 for asphalt shingles)

• Fewer repairs and replacements

• Better energy efficiency, lowering heating and cooling costs

• Higher resale value, especially for eco-conscious buyers

Over time, a metal roof pays for itself and then some.

Myth #3: Metal Roofs Attract Lightning

Truth: Metal roofs do not increase your chances of a lightning strike, and may actually make your home safer if one occurs.

Metal is conductive, but it doesn’t “attract” lightning. Trees, tall buildings, and utility poles are far more likely to take the hit. In the rare case that lightning does strike, a metal roof:

• Disperses electrical energy safely

• Doesn’t ignite (unlike wood shingles)

• Reduces fire risk, making it a safer choice overall

Myth #4: Metal Roofs Rust

Truth: Modern metal roofs are engineered to resist corrosion for decades.

Most metal roofing systems are made of galvanized steel, aluminum, zinc, or copper, and they’re coated with protective layers that prevent rust.

Even in Edmonton’s snow-heavy winters and wet springs, a properly installed metal roof will remain rust-free for 40 years or more.

Myth #5: Metal Roofs Are Bad in Cold Climates

Truth: Metal roofs are actually ideal for Alberta weather. In fact, metal roofing is one of the best defenses against snow, ice, and wind:

• Snow slides off more easily, reducing roof load and ice dams

• Seamless panels prevent leaks during freeze-thaw cycles

• Metal doesn’t absorb water, unlike porous materials like wood or asphalt

• Wind resistance ratings often exceed 140 km/h, perfect for storm season

So if you're dealing with Edmonton’s notorious weather swings, metal may be your roof’s new best friend.

Myth #6: Metal Roofs Are Only for Commercial Buildings

Truth: Metal roofing is now one of the most stylish options for residential homes. Modern metal roofs come in:

• Standing seam panels with sleek, vertical lines

• Shingle-style designs that mimic traditional roofing

• A range of colours, finishes, and textures that suit everything from farmhouses to ultra-modern builds

In fact, many high-end custom homes use metal to create curb appeal and lasting protection.

Myth #7: You Can’t Install Metal Over an Existing Roof

Truth: In many cases, you can install metal roofing over your current shingles, saving time, cost, and mess.

As long as the existing roof is structurally sound, metal can often be installed as a second layer, eliminating the need for a tear-off.

At J & D Independent Roofing Inc., we always assess your current roof first, but in many cases, this method:

• Cuts installation costs

• Reduces landfill waste

• Speeds up the timeline

• Improves insulation between layers

Metal vs. Asphalt

Which Roof Reigns Supreme?

Feature	Asphalt Shingles	Metal Roofing
Average Lifespan	12–20 years	40–70 years
Energy Efficiency	Moderate	High (reflects heat & cold)
Weather Resistance	Prone to curling/blow-off	Excellent (wind, hail, snow)
Fire Resistance	Fair	Excellent
Eco-Friendliness	Low (petroleum-based)	High (recyclable materials)
Maintenance Needs	Frequent	Minimal
Insurance Discounts?	Rare	Often available for Class 4 rating
Aesthetic Options	Traditional look	Modern, sleek, and customizable

Is a Metal Roof Right for You?

If you’re looking for:

• Durability that outlasts decades

• Lower energy bills

• Better storm protection

• Elevated curb appeal

…then yes, metal may be your perfect match. That said, every property is different. A good metal roofing job starts with a conversation, not just a quote.

At J & D Independent Roofing Inc., we provide:

• Free on-site assessments

• Honest recommendations

• High-quality metal roof installations for residential, commercial, and industrial buildings

• Full warranties and follow-up support

• Specialized service for flat and steep-slope roofing systems

Why Choose J & D Independent Roofing Inc.?

Located right here in Edmonton, Alberta, we’re not just your local roofing company, we’re your neighbors. Our owner-operated business brings over 30 years of hands-on experience, specializing in:

• Flat roofs for commercial and residential buildings

• Leak-proof roofing systems built for Alberta’s wildest weather

• Full metal roofing installs, inspections, and repairs

We don’t chase trends. We deliver results that last.

Ready to Make the Switch?

Still unsure? That’s okay. We’ll help you understand the pros, cons, and costs so you can make the right call for your home or business.

No pressure. No nonsense. Just expert advice from Edmonton’s most trusted roofers.

📍 Based in Edmonton, Alberta

📞 Call us at 780-447-1360

💻 Book your consultation: https://www.jdindependentroofing.ca/contact-us